Abstract
The relevance of the research is driven by the need to find a balance between the principle of freedom of contract and legal paternalism in the field of consumer lending. The article analyzes the evolution and modern mechanisms for regulating usurious interest. A comparative legal analysis of foreign jurisdictions regarding usurious loans is conducted.
Particular attention is paid to the analysis of the Law of Ukraine No. 3498-IX, which introduced a mandatory maximum daily interest rate. The temporal aspects of the legislative changes, including the mechanism of the transition period and the peculiarities of applying new rules to different types of agreements, are investigated.
Legal means for «adjusting» usurious terms, in particular through the institution of partial nullity, are revealed. It is demonstrated that the application of Article 217 of the Civil Code of Ukraine allows courts to exercise effective ex post control and serves as an effective instrument for protecting the weaker party. The practical significance of the study lies in the systematization of the legal consequences of violating the mandatory rule regarding the maximum daily interest rate and the formulation of recommendations for the judicial interpretation of norms on the nullity of terms in consumer credit agreements to ensure fairness and a balance of interests among financial market participants.
How to Cite
In accordance with DSTU 8302:2015:
Крат В. Діалектика свободи договору та правового патерналізму: регулювання лихварських процентів у договорі про споживчий кредит. Цивілістична платформа. 2026. № 3 (10). С. 41-53. https://doi.org/10.69724/2786-8834-2026-10-41-53
According to the international style of APA:
Krat, V. (2026) Dialectics of freedom of contract and legal paternalism: regulation of usurious interest in a consumer credit agreement . С. P. Journal, 3 (10). https://doi.org/10.69724/2786-8834-2026-10-41-53 [in Ukrainian].
References
- Thayer JB, ‘Laesio enormis’ (1937) 25(4) Kentucky Law Journal 321 <https://uknowledge.uky.edu/klj/vol25/iss4/3> accessed 21 May 2026.
- Giordano A (ed), Commentario breve al Codice civile: Aggiornato alla Riforma Cartabia e al d.lgs. 2 marzo 2023, n. 19 (Edizioni Ad Maiora 2023) 2393–2395.
- ZEW, Study on Interest Rate Restrictions in the EU: Final Report for the European Commission DG Internal Market and Services, Project No ETD/2009/IM/H3/87 (2010) <https://op.europa.eu/o/opportal-service/download-handler?identifier=46a336d0-18a0-4b46-8262-74f0e0f47eb3&format=pdf&language=en&productionSystem=cellar&part=iff> accessed 14 July 2026.
- Kanayama Naoki, ‘Struggles against Usurious Loans in Japan’ (2012) 2(2) Sogang Journal of Law and Business 53–72 <https://scc.sogang.ac.kr/Download?pathStr=NTYjIzUxIyM5NSMjNDgjIzQ5IyM5OCMjOTUjIzExNSMjMTE2IyMxMTUjIzEwNSMjMTA4IyM5NSMjNTAjIzQ4IyM0OCMjMTA4IyM5NyMjMTEwIyMxMTQjIzExNyMjMTExIyMxMDYjIzk1IyMxMDgjIzk3IyMxMTAjIzExNCMjMTE3IyMxMTEjIzEwNiMjNDcjIzExNiMjMTE1IyMxMTAjIzEwNSMjMTE5IyM5NyMjMTA4IyM5NSMjMTE1IyMxMDEjIzExNiMjMTA1IyMxMTUjIzQ3IyMxMTUjIzk4IyM5OCMjNDcjIzEyNCMjMTA0IyMxMTYjIzk3IyM4MCMjMTAxIyMxMDgjIzEwNSMjMTAyIyMzNSMjMzMjIzM1IyM0OSMjMTI0IyMxMjAjIzEwMSMjMTAwIyMxMTAjIzEwNSMjMzUjIzMzIyMzNSMjNDkjIzEyNCMjMTAwIyMxMDUjIzEwNyMjMTEy&fileName=%5B2%5D+struggles+against+usurious+loans+in+japan.pdf&gubun=oldbbs>accessed 14 July 2026.
- Krat VI, ‘Commentary on Article 632: Price’ in Spasybo-Fateyeva IV (ed), Civil Code of Ukraine: Scientific and Practical Commentary. Vol 5: Law of Obligations (EKUS 2026) 882–891.
- Krat VI, ‘Chapter 5: Obligations: Grounds for Arising and Termination’ in Spasybo-Fateуeva IV (gen ed), Civil and Commercial Codes: 2004–2014 (Pravo 2014) 122–123.
- Krat VI, ‘Commentary on Article 628: Content of the Contract’ in Spasybo-Fateуeva IV (ed), Civil Code of Ukraine: Scientific and Practical Commentary. Vol 5: Law of Obligations (EKUS 2026) 844–852.
- Krat VI, ‘§ 5 of Chapter 3: Invalidity of a Legal Act in the Sphere of Protection of Ownership Rights’ in Spasybo-Fateуeva IV (ed), Ownership Rights: Methods of Protection Through the Lens of Judicial Practice (EKUS 2023) 461–480.
